Last updated 4 months ago
Voters face decision fatigue, and reviews lack trustworthiness due to low-effort input, making it hard to assess proposal quality or reviewer credibility across all other ecosystem services.
A decentralized, merit-based reputation engine that evaluates user effort and engagement to enhance trust, accountability, and review all by evaluating all users activity reliability in cardano.
This is the total amount allocated to Merit Based Decentralized Repuation Engine.
Please provide your proposal title
Merit Based Decentralized Repuation Engine
Enter the amount of funding you are requesting in ADA
100000
Please specify how many months you expect your project to last
6
Please indicate if your proposal has been auto-translated
No
Original Language
en
What is the problem you want to solve?
Voters face decision fatigue, and reviews lack trustworthiness due to low-effort input, making it hard to assess proposal quality or reviewer credibility across all other ecosystem services.
Supporting links
Does your project have any dependencies on other organizations, technical or otherwise?
No
Describe any dependencies or write 'No dependencies'
No dependencies, we built it internally
Will your project's outputs be fully open source?
Yes
License and Additional Information
The project’s software components (e.g., tools, libraries and codes) will be released under the MIT License and GNU GPL-3.0 . This allows others to freely use, modify, distribute, and sublicense the code, provided the original license and copyright notice are included.
Please choose the most relevant theme and tag related to the outcomes of your proposal.
Governance
Describe what makes your idea innovative compared to what has been previously funded (whether by you or others).
Unlike traditional reputation systems that rely on simple voting or subjective reviews, our engine introduces merit-based scoring using verifiable behavioral metrics like time-spent reading and engagement depth. While others focus on static ratings, we create dynamic, tamper-proof reputation that rewards genuine effort over quantity. Our hybrid on-chain/off-chain architecture ensures immutability while maintaining scalability - a unique combination not seen in previous Catalyst-funded projects.
Describe what your prototype or MVP will demonstrate, and where it can be accessed.
Our MVP will demonstrate a working reputation engine with: (1) RESTful API calculating merit-based scores from user behavioral data, (2) Smart contract on Cardano testnet storing immutable reputation records, (3) Interactive dashboard showing real-time reputation analytics, (4) Integration module for Catalyst/IdeaScale-like platforms. Accessible via: GitHub repository (open-source code), live API documentation (Swagger), testnet smart contract explorer, and demo dashboard URL with sample data visualization.
Describe realistic measures of success, ideally with on-chain metrics.
On-chain metrics: Number of addresses with reputation scores stored on testnet, transaction volume of reputation updates, smart contract interaction frequency. Platform metrics: API call volume (target: 1000+/month), integration adoption rate, average user engagement time improvement (target: 40% increase). Quality indicators: Correlation between high-reputation reviewers and successful proposal outcomes, reduction in low-effort reviews (measured by time-spent analytics), community satisfaction scores via surveys (target: 70+ NPS).
Please describe your proposed solution and how it addresses the problem

With the rise of online marketplaces, social networks, web3 social platforms, DeFi service providers, and so on, individuals and businesses are constantly being evaluated based on their reputation or trustworthiness.
However, traditional reputation systems can be easily manipulated and are often not transparent or tamper-proof. To address these issues, a new type of reputation system is needed: a Merit Based Decentralized Reputation System.
Decentralized Architecture
Merit-Based Reputation Scoring
Behavioral Tracking
Reputation Scoring Algorithm
Considers:
Decentralized Storage
Use Cardano testnet smart contracts for on-chain data.
Store supporting data off-chain in scalable DB.
Integration Point
The Reputation Engine Model will revolutionize the way users interact with cardano projects and across all cardano ecosystems. By analyzing historical data and user activity, the model will assign trust scores to participants based on their past contributions, reviews, and behavior within the platforms and also for the new users.
Key Takeaways:
blockchain technology – transparent, accurate, immutable!
To address these challenges, our proposed solution involves a comprehensive research approaches:
A decentralized reputation system, which uses blockchain technology, would make sure that everyone has a unique digital identity and that reputation data is accurate and reliable. This way, we can trust the reviews and scores, and the whole ecosystem can thrive using the reputation system.
A decentralized reputation system that is enabled by blockchain technology can help to address these issues by providing a transparent and tamper-proof record of reputation data. This can ensure that all users have unique digital identities and that reputation data is accurate and reliable. By using a decentralized system, it becomes much harder for bad actors to manipulate the system and deceive users.
Additionally, a decentralized reputation system also allows for more privacy, as users can have more control over their personal data and who can access it, unlike centralized systems where data is owned and controlled by a single entity.

The first and foremost is Research:
Utilizing data from previous funding rounds up to Fund 13, we will conduct a thorough analysis. Leveraging Catalyst Testnet, cardano catalyst Platform, Milestone Reporting, and Community Reviewing data, we aim to:
Establish correlations between reviews, voting decisions, and proposal outcomes.
Develop a knowledge graph and perform a graph/network analysis to identify quality reviewers and voters.
The current and latest initial dataset of latest last funds can be found ‘https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1R-wytihG4fKR_E1hvSh8CWbYajo8dLcOezogxJ_7OSU/edit#gid=0’ and also

on the platform looks like this:
Upon successful implementation of the Proof of Concept, we will engage the Cardano community to gather feedback and refine the reputation system further. Community engagement is vital to ensure the system's alignment with the needs and preferences of Catalyst stakeholders.
Importance of Reputation Engine
More on The Benefits of Decentralized Reputation Systems can be found Here on Linkedin, Coreto Decentralization
Therefore implementing a reputation system is not just a feature enhancement; it's a strategic investment in building a robust, trustworthy, and sustainable community ecosystem that indicates “DECENTRALIZATION SYSTEM FOR A DECENTRALIZED PLATFORM”.
“Trust is the firm belief in the reliability, truth, or ability of someone or something.”
Being a belief, it’s inherently subjective. We put our trust in others for different reasons:
they make a compelling argumentothers hold them in high regard they have a history of speaking the truth
we have a previously established relationship with them and so on.
Finding the perfect balance and improving the trust score indicator
What this means is that it doesn’t matter if we have 100 or 100,000 people interacting with our content. What matters is how their interaction changes, how they view our content, if they continue to consider it useful and whether they continue to view us as a trusted source of content or not.
So our DRS Use the main core activity of users called Time-Spent
In this reputation system, Time spent refers to how long a user actively engages with a proposal. It’s a key indicator used to assess whether a user’s action—such as reviewing or voting—is genuine or just superficial. More time spent reading and interacting with a proposal suggests a higher level of effort, making their contribution more credible and impactful in the reputation scoring.
As the first component of the DRS, it handles collecting Trust and Performance data by linking to relevant actions, events, and data feeds from the platforms that integrated the system.
The role of the RCS is crucial as it provides the data that is used to calculate the reputation scores. The accuracy and reliability of the data directly impact the credibility of the reputation score. It also has to be flexible enough that it can be linked to any relevant KPIs inside the said platforms.
The RCS is and will be designed as a set of developer tools and APIs that allow for:
The first tools we built were meant to serve our own SingularityNet and Mindplex Platform and are actively being used as part of our own integration of the DRS. This has helped us to experiment and adjust, and identify the best ways to also make them available for other platforms as well.
And General Project catalyst Research and Reports can be Found Here: https://projectcatalyst.io/reports/horizons.pdf
Evaluations of Fund 11 Cardano Catalyst Announcement show found - https://twitter.com/danny_cryptofay/status/1770800625829179634/photo/1


Community network actions are at the heart of Project Catalyst


Please define the positive impact your project will have on the wider Cardano community
The implementation of the Merit-Based Decentralized Reputation Engine will have a far-reaching impact on the Cardano ecosystem and beyond:
Improved Proposal Quality
Enhanced Community Trust
Efficient Resource Allocation
Sustainable Ecosystem Growth
On-Chain + Off-Chain Architecture
Cross-Platform Reputation Service (SaaS/API)
Higher Reviewer Accountability
Data-Driven Governance & Research
Qualitative Measurement
Proposal Quality Improvement
Community Trust Enhancement
Reviewer Behavior Change
Governance Transparency
Third-Party Ecosystem Value
Quantitative Measurement
On-Chain Metrics (via Cardano Testnet)
Platform Integration Rate
Engagement & Trust Metrics

While the initial integration is designed for Project Catalyst, the architecture is modular and open — enabling adoption across:
This project builds a foundation for decentralized trust at scale — starting with Cardano, but usable far beyond them.
The publication of the number of positive and negative vote casts received by each proposal was disabled since Fund5. Link is here from Catalyst forum (https://forum.cardano.org/t/project-catalyst-fund-10-reflections-what-works-what-doesnt/122186/10))
Imagein what it will do in case of the whole voting, and funding of the project catalyst system, this is a snap of just only voting researches of the last funds

What is your capability to deliver your project with high levels of trust and accountability? How do you intend to validate if your approach is feasible?
Our capability to deliver this project with high levels of trust and accountability stems from our team's extensive experience in software development, education, and community engagement. With a proven track record of delivering successful projects and initiatives within the blockchain space, we possess the expertise and dedication required to execute this proposal effectively.
Our previous experience with blockchain integration Cardano projects funded by Catalyst in the previous funding round, including:
highlights our commitment and proven ability to deliver impactful projects.
Our team is proud to be partnered with MLOps Community (https://mlops.community/) a global organization at the forefront of machine learning, DevOps, and cutting-edge technology. With branches in various countries and partnerships with industry leaders like AWS, NVIDIA, Databricks and more, we have demonstrated our capacity to deliver successful events and initiatives, showcasing our commitment to innovation and community engagement.


Also we are an Official Partner With Microsoft Startup Founder Hub, We receive more than 45 AI related Microsoft products with a mix of technical benefits and business resources.
We’re trusted by Microsoft!

Previous Success Recap:
We are Simply Highly Experienced programmers in haskell, plutus, solidity, AI, ML and subject matter experts ensure high-quality resources.
Marketing and Promotion Plan:
Milestone Title
Research Foundation & System Architecture
Milestone Outputs
Complete comprehensive research and system design phase establishing the foundation for our merit-based reputation engine. This includes analyzing existing decentralized reputation systems, conducting stakeholder interviews within the Cardano community, and designing the technical architecture. We will structure historical Catalyst data from Funds 1-13 for analysis, create detailed API specifications, and develop the core algorithm for merit-based scoring using time-spent and engagement metrics. Deliverables include technical documentation, system architecture diagrams, database schemas, API specifications, and community feedback analysis. The research will inform our behavioral tracking methodology and establish baseline metrics for reputation calculation algorithms.
Acceptance Criteria
Research report analyzing minimum 5 existing reputation systems with comparative analysis completed. Community feedback collected from minimum 15 stakeholders including proposers, reviewers, and voters through structured interviews and surveys. Technical architecture document created showing on-chain/off-chain data flow, smart contract specifications, and API endpoints. Database schema designed for storing behavioral metrics, reputation scores, and user interactions. Core reputation algorithm documented with mathematical formulas for merit-based scoring. All documentation reviewed and approved by minimum 2 technical advisors. Historical Catalyst data from previous funds structured and analyzed for patterns in reviewer behavior and proposal outcomes.
Evidence of Completion
Public GitHub repository created with comprehensive README and project documentation. Research report published as PDF (minimum 15 pages) on Google Drive with community access. Technical architecture diagrams created in Figma and exported as PNG/PDF formats. Database schema documentation with entity-relationship diagrams. API specification document using OpenAPI/Swagger format. Community feedback summary report with anonymized insights and recommendations. Video presentation (10-15 minutes) explaining the research findings and proposed solution architecture available on YouTube or similar platform.
Delivery Month
1
Cost
15000
Progress
20 %
Milestone Title
Backend Development & API Creation
Milestone Outputs
Develop robust backend infrastructure using Django Python framework with PostgreSQL database for storing reputation data and user interactions. Create comprehensive RESTful API with endpoints for reputation calculation, user behavior tracking, and data retrieval. Implement core business logic for merit-based scoring algorithm including time-spent analysis, engagement depth measurement, and reputation weight calculations. Set up Docker containerization for consistent deployment environments and implement CI/CD pipeline using GitHub Actions for automated testing and deployment. Create Swagger documentation for all API endpoints with request/response examples. Establish secure authentication and authorization mechanisms for API access. Database migrations and seed data for testing purposes will be implemented.
Acceptance Criteria
Django backend application fully functional with minimum 15 API endpoints including user management, reputation calculation, behavioral tracking, and analytics. PostgreSQL database implemented with optimized queries and proper indexing for performance. Docker configuration files created enabling one-command deployment across different environments. CI/CD pipeline established with automated testing achieving minimum 80% code coverage. Swagger API documentation accessible via web interface with interactive testing capabilities. Authentication system implemented supporting API key management and rate limiting. Performance benchmarks achieved: API response times under 200ms for standard queries, database queries optimized for concurrent users. All code follows PEP 8 standards and includes comprehensive docstrings.
Evidence of Completion
Live backend API deployed on AWS/cloud infrastructure with public endpoint for testing. Interactive Swagger documentation accessible via web URL showing all available endpoints. GitHub repository updated with complete backend codebase, Docker files, and CI/CD configuration. Database schema visualization and migration files committed to repository. Postman collection file with sample API requests and automated tests. Performance testing report showing API response times and concurrent user handling capabilities. Unit test results showing minimum 80% coverage with detailed testing report. Video demonstration (15-20 minutes) showcasing API functionality and key features.
Delivery Month
2
Cost
25000
Progress
40 %
Milestone Title
Smart Contract Development & Testnet Deployment
Milestone Outputs
Design and implement smart contracts for Cardano testnet using Plutus/Haskell to store immutable reputation scores and key behavioral metrics on-chain. Create smart contract functions for reputation score updates, historical data retrieval, and verification of off-chain calculations. Develop integration layer connecting Django backend with Cardano testnet through appropriate APIs and SDKs. Implement data synchronization mechanisms ensuring consistency between on-chain and off-chain systems. Create comprehensive test suite for smart contract functionality including edge cases and error handling. Deploy contracts to Cardano testnet with proper verification and documentation. Establish monitoring and alerting systems for smart contract interactions and performance tracking.
Acceptance Criteria
Smart contracts successfully deployed on Cardano testnet with verified source code and documentation. Minimum 5 core functions implemented: store reputation score, update user metrics, retrieve historical data, verify off-chain calculations, and handle error scenarios. Integration layer successfully connecting Django backend with testnet contracts through reliable API calls. Data synchronization tested showing consistency between on-chain stored scores and off-chain calculations with maximum 1% deviation. Smart contract audit completed identifying and resolving security vulnerabilities. Gas/fee optimization implemented ensuring cost-effective transactions. Comprehensive test coverage of minimum 90% for all smart contract functions with successful execution of 100+ test transactions on testnet.
Evidence of Completion
Cardano testnet transaction hashes and smart contract addresses publicly accessible through blockchain explorer. Smart contract source code committed to GitHub repository with comprehensive documentation and deployment instructions. Integration testing report showing successful data synchronization between backend and blockchain. Testnet transaction examples demonstrating all key smart contract functions with verifiable results. Smart contract audit report (internal or external) documenting security analysis and recommendations. Performance metrics documentation showing transaction costs and execution times. Video walkthrough (20-25 minutes) demonstrating smart contract deployment, integration, and key functionality on testnet.
Delivery Month
4
Cost
30000
Progress
70 %
Milestone Title
Frontend Development & User Interface
Milestone Outputs
Develop comprehensive web-based user interface using modern frontend technologies (React/Vue.js) providing intuitive dashboards for viewing reputation scores, behavioral analytics, and system insights. Create responsive design supporting desktop and mobile devices with accessibility compliance (WCAG 2.1). Implement real-time data visualization using charts and graphs showing reputation trends, user engagement metrics, and system performance indicators. Develop user management interfaces allowing profile creation, API key management, and preference settings. Create admin panel for system monitoring, user management, and analytics overview. Integrate frontend with backend API ensuring secure data transmission and efficient loading. Implement comprehensive error handling and user feedback mechanisms throughout the interface.
Acceptance Criteria
Fully functional web application deployed with responsive design working on desktop, tablet, and mobile devices. User authentication and registration system integrated with backend API supporting secure login/logout functionality. Minimum 8 core pages implemented: dashboard, profile management, reputation analytics, behavioral insights, API documentation, admin panel, settings, and help/support. Real-time charts and graphs displaying reputation data, user engagement metrics, and system statistics with interactive filtering and date range selection. Frontend performance optimized with loading times under 3 seconds for standard pages and proper caching mechanisms. Cross-browser compatibility tested on Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge with consistent functionality. User experience testing completed with minimum 5 beta testers providing feedback and recommendations.
Evidence of Completion
Live web application accessible via public URL with complete functionality demonstration. GitHub repository updated with frontend source code, build configurations, and deployment documentation. User interface mockups and final designs created in Figma with complete design system documentation. Cross-browser testing report showing compatibility across major web browsers. Performance audit report using tools like Lighthouse showing optimization scores and recommendations. Beta testing feedback summary with user experience insights and implemented improvements. Mobile responsiveness demonstration showing functionality across different device sizes. Video tour (15-20 minutes) of complete user interface showcasing all key features and user workflows.
Delivery Month
5
Cost
20000
Progress
80 %
Milestone Title
Integration, Testing, Promotion & Production Deployment
Milestone Outputs
Complete end-to-end system integration connecting frontend, backend, smart contracts, and external APIs into fully operational reputation engine. Conduct comprehensive testing including unit tests, integration tests, performance testing, and user acceptance testing. Implement production deployment with proper security configurations, monitoring systems, and backup procedures. Create detailed documentation including user guides, API documentation, deployment instructions, and maintenance procedures. Establish community feedback collection mechanisms and support channels. Prepare final project report with detailed analysis of achievements, lessons learned, and future development roadmap. Implement analytics and monitoring systems for tracking system usage, performance metrics, and user engagement patterns. Promotion in different social media for the community will be done.
Acceptance Criteria
Complete system integration tested and operational with all components (frontend, backend, smart contracts) working seamlessly together. Production deployment completed on reliable cloud infrastructure with proper security configurations, SSL certificates, and automated backups. Comprehensive documentation package including user manual, API documentation, deployment guide, and troubleshooting instructions. System performance validated supporting minimum 100 concurrent users with response times under 500ms. Security audit completed with penetration testing and vulnerability assessment. Community beta testing program executed with minimum 20 active testers providing feedback over 2-week period. Analytics dashboard operational showing real-time system metrics, user engagement, and performance indicators. Final project report completed documenting achievements, metrics, lessons learned, and future enhancement recommendations. Promotion for the cardano ecosystem and prepare reports
Evidence of Completion
Production system accessible via public URL with full functionality and stable performance. Complete documentation package published on GitHub and project website including video tutorials. Security audit report documenting assessment results and implemented security measures. Performance testing report showing load testing results and system capacity metrics. Community beta testing summary with participant feedback and system improvements implemented. Analytics dashboard screenshots showing system usage metrics, user engagement data, and performance indicators. Final project report (minimum 25 pages) with comprehensive analysis, achievements, and future roadmap. Project presentation video (30-35 minutes) demonstrating complete system functionality and showcasing key achievements and community impact.
Delivery Month
6
Cost
10000
Progress
100 %
Please provide a cost breakdown of the proposed work and resources
A detailed budget breakdown encompassing expenses related to development, testing, deployment, and ongoing maintenance of the Reputation Engine. We are committed to transparent financial management and accountability throughout the project lifecycle.
Development Costs:
Infrastructure Costs:
Testing and Quality Assurance:
Documentation and Reporting:
Miscellaneous Expenses:
Risk Mitigation Reserve:
Total Budget: 100,000 ADA
How does the cost of the project represent value for the Cardano ecosystem?
The proposed budget represents a high-value investment in the long-term integrity and effectiveness of the Cardano ecosystem.
By building a Merit-Based Decentralized Reputation Engine, this project enhances trust, accountability, and transparency — three pillars essential for any decentralized governance system. It directly supports platforms like catalyst and beyond, while also offering a reusable API model that can serve DAOs, grant systems, and governance dApps across the Cardano ecosystem.
Efficient Resource Allocation
Reusable Across Ecosystems
Data-Driven and Auditable
Clear Reporting and Progress Tracking
Budget Transparency
Stakeholder Attraction
Long-Term Ecosystem Value
Together, this project is not just a tool — it’s a foundation for integrity and growth in Cardano’s governance, funding, and community engagement systems. The value far outweighs the cost.
Terms and Conditions:
Yes
1. Martreza Eshetu(BSs/MSs): Project Manager | Technical Lead | Blockchain Strategist
2. Roza Kassa - Fullstack developer | Node.js | React | svelte | Next.js | sveltekit | Postgres | Typescript | Docker | UI/UX
3. Gerawork Aynekulu - Experianced Blockchain Developer | Senior Backend Developer | AWS certified

4. Abel Ayalew - Full Stack Developer | Backend Developer (Django, Node.js, Python, PostgreSQL, MongoDB) | Google Developer Lead
5. Ruth Teferra - Marketing Executive at SingularityNET | Business Developer | HR | Building Bridges in AI Ecosystems
6. Amanuel Mersha - AI/ML Engineer & Researcher | Head of AI at TestSavantAI | An ML researcher and engineer specializing in deep learning, with a focus on vision and NLP applications, as showcased research and professional experience
7. Partners and Groups with existing educational and experienced experts
Team Engagement: All listed team members have been engaged and have confirmed their roles and commitment to the project timelines.